Every gardener faces the same choice each season: sow seeds, or buy plants that are already growing? Seeds are cheaper and offer endless variety. Live plants — starts, plugs and potted plants — save weeks and much of the uncertainty. The best gardens usually mix both, depending on the plant.
Side by side
| Seeds | Live plants / plugs | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost per plant | Very low | Higher |
| Time to harvest or bloom | Longest | Weeks to months shorter |
| Variety | Huge, including rare and heirloom types | More limited |
| Success rate | Depends on germination, light and care | Higher; the hardest stage is done |
| Equipment | Trays, compost, often grow lights | Little |
| Transplant shock | None for direct-sown crops | Possible; plants need hardening off |
| Shipping risk | Low | Plants can be stressed by transit |
See 22% OFF at Clovers Garden →
When seeds win
- Fast, easy crops you sow directly: radishes, beans, peas, carrots, lettuce and many annual flowers.
- Root crops such as carrots and parsnips, which dislike being transplanted.
- Large quantities, like a wildflower meadow or a whole row of greens.
- Unusual varieties you can't find as plants.
When live plants win
- Slow starters: peppers, tomatoes, aubergines and many herbs take weeks indoors from seed.
- Perennials, shrubs and ground covers, which can take a year or more to establish from seed.
- Short seasons, where there isn't time to grow from seed outdoors.
- Filling gaps quickly, or when you want a predictable result.
Getting the most from each
Seeds
- Check the packet's sowing window for your region and frost dates.
- Give seedlings strong light; leggy seedlings usually mean too little light.
- Harden off indoor-started seedlings over a week before planting out.
Live plants
- Unpack mail-order plants straight away, water them and let them recover in shade for a day or two.
- Harden off before planting in full sun.
- Plant at the same depth as in the pot, water deeply and keep them watered while they establish.
Cost and time, worked through
A simple example shows the trade-off. Say you want twelve tomato plants:
| From seed | Buying plants | |
|---|---|---|
| What you buy | One seed packet, seed-starting mix, trays (reusable), maybe a grow light | Twelve young plants |
| Start | Sow indoors about 6–8 weeks before your last frost | Plant out after the last frost |
| Effort | Daily checks, watering, potting up, hardening off | Hardening off and planting |
| Risk | Poor germination, leggy seedlings, damping off | Transplant shock, limited variety |
The first year of seed starting costs more because of equipment; in later years seeds become much cheaper per plant. If you only need a few plants of a slow-growing crop, buying plants is often the better deal. For perennials, shrubs and ground covers, which can take a year or more from seed, live plants usually win outright.
Checking mail-order plants on arrival
- Leaves are green, not yellow or slimy
- The root ball is moist and holds together
- No pests under the leaves or on the soil
- Stems are firm, not broken at the base
Photograph any damage straight away in case you need to contact the seller.
About Clovers Garden
Clovers Garden describes itself as a family business that has been growing plants since 1957, and sells live plants online — shrubs, ground covers, flowering plants and more — with a rating it lists as 4.6 out of 5 from more than 746 reviews. It also sells through Amazon, Walmart and Etsy. If you're buying live plants by mail, check the shipping season for your area and plan to plant soon after delivery.
Conclusion
Choose seeds for cheap, fast, direct-sown crops, root vegetables, large quantities and rare varieties. Choose live plants or plugs for slow starters, perennials, shrubs, short seasons and quick results. Most gardens benefit from both: sow what grows easily, and buy what takes the longest to get going.
If you're ready to buy, Clovers Garden is worth checking — they currently have 22% off with code DISCOUNT10 live right now.
If you're ready to buy, Clovers Garden is worth checking — they currently have 22% off with code DISCOUNT10 live right now.
Get 22% OFF at Clovers Garden
Use code DISCOUNT10 at checkout
This article contains an affiliate link. If you buy through it, The Chiehub may earn a commission at no extra cost to you — see our affiliate disclosure.